By Avery Hunt
One of Phippsburg’s least known communities is Brightwater, a 125-acre pear-shaped peninsula bordering the New Meadows River to the northwest and The Basin to the southeast. This largely wooded point is connected to the mainland by a narrow strip of land about 400 feet wide and borders the famous Narrows to the southwest. The aptly named Narrows is an almost invisible tidal passage that leads into The Basin, which has long been a storm refuge for sailors and known as the best hidey-hole to ride out a hurricane on the coast of Maine.
The reason the community is relatively unknown is that Brightwater itself is a strictly private enclave of modest cabins owned by 16 families of mostly summer folks from away. These same families have spent summers there for at least three generations.
The original families first incorporated this quiet piece of Maine waterfront in 1926, and formally dubbed it “The Brightwater Club,” which sounds way fancier than it was then and or even is today. There are no tennis or pickleball courts, no pool, and certainly no golf course or club house. In short: no pretensions, a simple place that is pretty much the same as it was 100 years ago.
Formed by a group of friends
It all started with a group of like-minded friends spearheaded by Rev. Jerome Davis, a professor at Yale Divinity School, who had a dream to create an ideal cooperative summer retreat. He contacted a bunch of his pals — mostly missionaries, educators, ministers and social workers from Yale, Dartmouth and Oberlin College. After much back and forth of letters, telegrams and phone calls, they gathered at the Hotel Commodore in New York City in 1925, signed the official documents and created the “Club.” By1926 all the formal bylaws were in place, and rustic cottages were being built, mostly by local carpenters.
What all these men wanted for themselves and their families was a leisurely getaway on the rural Maine coast, far from the heat and bustle of cities. They sought the simple pleasures of fishing, sailing, blueberry picking, and communal sings and picnics. In those days, many of them had the luxury of the whole summer to do so.
The Club owned the communal land, while the 16 families owned only their individual cabins. For years, there was no electricity (until 1949!) or running water. Only one road, the so-called “Boulevard,” circled the peninsula and it was a bit of a wreck. Each summer the men and boys were recruited to shovel dirt in the ruts and otherwise attempt minimal maintenance.

The 52 lots of the “New Venice”
Getting there from away was also a trek. The annual trip to Brightwater from New York or beyond sometimes took two to three days with lots of stops along the way on old Route 1. But once on the peninsula, all was bliss. These folks were rusticators indeed.Dreams of “New Venice”
It wasn’t always like this. In 1901, an ambitious group of men — mostly from away, but including one from Bath — had a very different idea for the land. They tried to transform a crumbling farm, which was all that was there back then, into an exclusive summer resort.
They named their project “New Venice” and created a fancy brochure promising the moon, including“ mosquito- and black fly-free” atmosphere, beaches (which turned out mostly to be small rocky coves), and a road carved in a circle around the peninsula and grandly named “The Boulevard,” which was nothing but a rough, rutted dirt road. A detailed site map envisioned a whopping 52 lots along the pristine wooded shores of Brightwater.
Despite all the hype, there was little interest from the public and the speculation deal faltered for years.
Then came the Great War, followed by the Roaring 20s, fueled in part by the invention of the automobile. People no longer wanted summer cottages; they wanted to travel far and think big. The promoters of New Venice threw in the towel and tried to sell the land for a whopping $50,000.They stuck to that price despite lower offers. No one took the bait, so they finally dropped the whole thing.
That’s when Jerome Davis stepped in. While visiting a local Phippsburg farm family for several summers in the early 1920s¸ he got to know the area and loved the rugged land. When he heard it was for sale, he bought the whole thing for $3,500, still a princely sum back then. He hoped to enlist some of his friends and colleagues to form a private association, help cover the land purchase and then build rustic cabins.
The rest is history.
Not much has changed. Yes, everyone has electricity and indoor plumbing. The “Boulevard” is improved but still unpaved. That’s just fine with the descendants. One of those descendants, Fred Blatchly, reminisced fondly in 1977: “I like Brightwater as it is now, still not too crowded, not polluted and not developed!” Still today, families continue to believe that Brightwater is “a perfect bit of paradise.”
Many thanks to Robert L. Lambert, an old Brightwater denizen. Bob first came here when he was just a twinkle in his father’s eye, and comfortably in utero, as he likes to say today, sailing with his mother on the breezy waters of the New Meadows aboard the family sailboat, Betsy. His lovingly published and meticulously researched book on the history of Brightwater commemorates its 50th anniversary and provided much valuable information for this piece. It is available to peruse at the Phippsburg Historical Society, Also, thanks to Alex Blachly and family, who offered their memories and photos.